How a musician and a Sikh TV channel dominated coverage of the Birmingham riots

Man holding bag of Tesco value rice

One image from last night guaranteed not to have made it onto the front page - via Birmingham Riots 2011

It’s one thing to cover rioting on the doorstep of the national press – it’s quite another when squeezed regional newsrooms have to do the same. And as rioting in the UK spread from London to Birmingham and then other cities, some unlikely suspects showed how to cover a riot online even when you don’t have a newsroom.

Dominating online coverage in Birmingham was not a local newspaper or broadcaster but a Tumblr site – Birmingham Riots 2011 – set up by musician Casey Rain. Over dozens of entries Casey posted countless reports of what was taking place, and a range of photos and video footage which dwarfed the combined coverage of regional press and broadcast.

Adopting the ‘publish, then filter‘ principle of online journalism, he continuously acknowledged the dozens of unfounded rumours going around. In doing so, however, he also provided a way to quickly separate the rumour from fact.

On Monday evening, for example, the site published an image of a rioter kicking a policeman – said to have been taken in Birmingham that night. Within an hour it had already been correctly identified as being taken in London in March.

The next day, however, the same image was incorrectly captioned on the front page of the Birmingham Mail and the centre spread of The Guardian, along with many other newspapers.

Casey, of course, isn’t a journalist, but he clearly cared passionately about informing his community. As a result, from a standing start he became the focal point of a network of people exchanging information about the riots, managing correspondence from people across multiple channels.

By publishing and then filtering, Casey acknowledged that the information was already out there, added notes of scepticism, and provided a means for others to confirm or debunk it. It was notable how the quality of his coverage improved from the first to the second day: a steep learning curve for anyone.

Sangat TV

Meanwhile, a small Sikh television channel on Sky Channel 847 and was also pioneering a unique style of “guerilla” broadcasting based on a similar passion for its community as rioting spread to the Black Country. (Chris Unitt described it as “the Sex Pistols to data journalism’s prog rock”).

Sangat TV’s website crashed due to high demand and they shifted to hosting their stream on Amazon’s servers. Meanwhile, some clips were filmed by viewers and posted on YouTube.

At one point the camera crew gave a lift to police pursuing rioters, the reporter commentating that they were “Serving the community”. It’s an action that challenges traditional notions of journalistic impartiality:

(Conversely, here another presenter confronts a policeman about their lack of action)

What is striking about the channel is how clearly it sees its role being embedded in the community: frequently giving a voice to its members; fearlessly filming events that affect it. In print and broadcast, that would be a disadvantage, limiting its market. Online, it gives the channel and its presenters a personality and unique flavour that users responded to.

UPDATE: More on the station in this Guardian profile by Josh Halliday

Parachute journalism

In contrast, when the BBC reported, briefly, on Birmingham’s riots there was a flurry of tweets complaining about the reporter getting street names wrong. “Clueless stringer“; “Eedgit … Hysterical bullshit“; “Have you ever *been* to Birmingham, fella?

The same channel was criticised for misinformation, and failing to correct a policeman who incorrectly claimed that a statue of a bull had had its head removed.

An image of the ‘decapitated’ bull was also posted on Birmingham Riots 2011 – but was quickly debunked.

And so on the one hand we had those who were looking at the story, and on the other those who were looking at the community; between product and process; content and context; impartiality and passion.

I’m not claiming that one approach is better than the other: broadcasters and bloggers have different audiences, different processes, and different concerns.

There’s room for both approaches – indeed, I would argue that it’s better to have both. All I want to do here is note that difference, and perhaps suggest that as journalists we should be more aware of that – especially when it comes to avoiding mistakes often made in covering an event or place we are not familiar with.

10 thoughts on “How a musician and a Sikh TV channel dominated coverage of the Birmingham riots

  1. Pingback: Twitted by BrownhillsBob

  2. Deborah Wilson

    The American concept of civic journalism extended and applied to community television – and a breath of fresh air!
    One BBC manager suggested to me that the reason their Manchester/Salford pictures were poor was because a cameraman had been assaulted – Was he suggesting there was only one camera operator? Or was he suggesting that the BBC had too few people on the ground who’d been adequately trained in such situations? Greenslade has written today regarding what is essentially a common sense approach to covering this kind of situation:
    It may well be that, for H&S reasons, the BBC had to pull untrained teams from the scene, leaving coverage very thin for a while – Sangat TV were not similarly restrained and with their own style and local knowledge served those who were more interested in what was happening in that community.

  3. LJ

    Casey Rain did a fantastic job of keeping everybody informed and updated. I’m from Birmingham but now live in Wales and I was concerned about friends and family still living there. His Tumblr page was always correct or advised people to wait until confirmation had happened of certain events. He was much more on the ball than the bbc or any other news provider.
    He should be commended for his dedication to his community and the number of hours he put in to report on the horrors of the last few days.
    Well done Casey! And thank you x

  4. H

    Could not agree more with this article, both Casey and Sangat TV have done a brilliant job during so much uncertainty and rumour, particularly as the Birmingham riots have received disappointingly disproportionate coverage on the main news channel. Well done to you all, People in Birmingham and the surrounding areas are very grateful!

  5. Tali

    I also grew up in birmingham, but have since moved further north. I found Casey Rain’s tumblr site when it had only a couple of posts. His blog enabled me to check out the situation in Bham, something I am very grateful for, so that I could ensure my friends and family were safe. I probably refreshed his site every 5 minutes over the last 48 hours! Thanks to the blog’s author to filter fiction from fact, and for keeping us updated on the state of our beloved city!

  6. Pingback: Birmingham riots: how Sangat TV is scooping the big networks – The Guardian

  7. Pingback: UK riots: Sikh TV channel’s coverage hailed – Economic Times

  8. Pingback: JOURNALISME PARTICIPATIF. Comment un musicien a donné une leçon de journalisme aux professionnels pendant les émeutes de Birmingham « La Social Newsroom

  9. Pingback: links for 08/12/2011 « Alan Vonlanthen's blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s