Schofield’s list, the mob and a very modern moral panic

Someone, somewhere right now will be writing a thesis, dissertation or journal paper about the very modern moral panic playing out across the UK media.

What began as a story about allegations of sexual abuse by TV and radio celebrity Jimmy Savile turned into a story about that story being covered up, into how the abuse could take place (at the BBC too, in the 1970s, but also in hospitals and schools), then into wider allegations of a paedophile ring involving politicians.

In the rush to find new angles on the Savile story, a story about sexual abuse and abuse of power was quickly reformed to fit a more familiar narrative about paedophilia. Other celebrity names were mentioned. Institutions were scrutinised. Old inquiries were seen in a new light; new inquiries were announced. Journalists were eager to find their own ‘sex abuse story’; politicians were eager to be seen to be acting.

But this moral panic took place in a different world to the previous panics about paedophiles. It took place with internet speed.

And yesterday, the media began to eat itself.

When daytime TV presenter Philip Schofield brandished a list of names in front of David Cameron, he was confronting the prime minister with the information reality that existed for many viewers. In doing so, however, he broke the illusion that the media is somehow separate from that information reality. And it provided the moral panic with a new direction.

That new direction was about an internet ‘witch hunt‘. About a ‘Cyberspace democracy‘ (yes, it really is 1993) of online rumour and the “values of the internet”, as one Radio 4 presenter called them. “The mob,” apparently, was in danger of taking over.

But if this was a mob then their pitchforks had been manufactured on Fleet Street; their torches lit with petrol-soaked newspaper.

If this was a Frankenstein’s monster, Frankenstein himself was here presenting a paper on “Why monsters are bad things and you need more scientists like me to stop it happening again.” Or “The values of the laboratory”.

This is not to blame the media for reflecting society or providing a forum for its members – that is part of their job. That is what Philip Schofield was actually trying to do, however badly. But to pretend that the media is somehow not part of the circus is disingenuous. The mob is us.

Meanwhile, hundreds of phonecalls to the police and to abuse helplines need following up, questions remain unanswered, and the circus is leaving town.

3 thoughts on “Schofield’s list, the mob and a very modern moral panic

  1. Lee Salter

    I was interviewed on BBC radio on this this morning. The gunning for Schofield was of course the main theme. When I suggested no one seemed to bother to wait to see what happened with Savile, I was told by the presenter, “he’s dead”. As if that’s a good enough reason to print rumour and suspicions. Still, it was the papers wot said it, and they’re not disposed to mobly behaviour now are then?!

  2. Graeme Stewart

    It’s a put up job. The Police want to shut the media up, because, stop to think a minute; – the Media give the Police a Bad Public Image and reputation, reporting all the gaffs, and the accidental deaths in police stations, the Tony Hamilton’s of this world and a thousand misdemeanors the public need to forget and move on from.

    The only Problem is, the Media give Politicians a very bad PR report too. So, I guess by even more allegations and illogical stabbings in the dark, I must conclude that the Police too are full of Pædophiliac tendencies in the ranks!?

    Well to quote the officer who I spoke to not long ago:
    “Calling someone a Pædophile can get you in a lot of trouble”.

    Have you ever been maliciously called by some self-appointed ‘enemy’ a ‘P-word’? I have. I had two broken windows, a broken leg, and five years years of chaos with kids chucking stones and eggs at my rented house, all based on the word of a … “Paranoid Schizophrenic” & Alcoholic neighbour.
    (My Quotes).

    And I have no criminal record whatsoever, Do you see yet what kind of damage slandering around “pædophile” stories can do?

    You people better wake up, and fast.
    FYI: – the Word is correctly spelt with the dipthong ‘æ’


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.