Tag Archives: tragedy of the commons

Caught in a trap: what journalists can learn from systems thinking

One of the most powerful ways to generate original journalism is to look at the systems behind stories — particularly the points where those systems fail.

For investigative work, those points are central. Surface-level scandals often stem from deeper systemic problems. So what tools do we have for recognising those patterns?

Donella Meadows’s classic book Thinking in Systems offers one: “system traps” — patterns that explain how systems get stuck, break down, or behave in ways nobody intends. They are “traps” because attempts to escape them often backfire.

System trap

Journalism examples

Policy resistance

The war on drugs; reforms that fail; missed targets

Overuse leading to shortages; climate change impacts; AI

Tragedy of the commons

Drift to low performance

Normalisation of poor performance or low productivity

Escalation

Arms races; races to the bottom

Success to the successful

Increasing concentration of wealth or resources

Shifting the burden to the intervenor

Subsidies, price fixes and delaying the impact/cost of a policy

Rule beating

Tax avoidance, loopholes

Seeking the wrong goal

Schools focusing on targets over pupil welfare;

In this post I’ll explain each trap, what it looks like in the wild, and how to use it as a lens for story ideas.

Continue reading