Ethics and data journalism: adding a new dimension to the data journalism pyramid

The Inverted Pyramid of Data Journalism Ethics

Conceive: Public interest, avoid harm, consider bias, giving a ‘voice to the voiceless’

Compile: Legal & ethical access, privacy, accuracy,  transparency, representativeness

Clean: Minimise errors, address bias, document changes, accuracy (outliers, duplication)

Context: Avoid misleading conclusions, provide context, ‘second source’ data

Combine: Accuracy, coherence, disclose methodological choices

Communicate: Accuracy, privacy (non-identification), avoid bias/stereotypes, accountability, transparency (source, limits, gaps & caveats), clarity, (including uncertainty), use of baselines & scales, equitable reporting

Here’s a version of the inverted pyramid of data journalism that shows ethical considerations at each stage, thanks to the research of Laurence Dierickx, Marilia Gehrke and Carl-Gustav Linden which I blogged about yesterday.

The research maps the stages of the pyramid of data journalism to different categories and ethical justifications.

I’ve also added some others.

Privacy, for example, is listed in the research in relation to compiling data, but it is also a (potentially bigger) concern in communication: for example you might choose to use a heatmap instead of a points map to avoid identifying individuals, so in my diagram I’ve included privacy in both.

Map with dots showing location of each gun permit  registration
This gun permit holders map was criticised for not considering privacy issues (image from Sherrie Questioning All)

I’ve also included mentioned uncertainty in communication, as this is a major issue in data visualisation and journalism more generally.

Verification is listed in the research in relation to the compile stage, but it might also be one of the reasons for combining data or putting it into context: both stages might involve checking data against a second source.

Cleaning also often involves checking for outliers that may have been misentered, and duplication

Finally at the conceive stage I’ve added the ethical consideration of ‘voice to the voiceless‘, i.e. not generating ideas solely from what data already exists, but considering what data is not being recorded or published (including missing categories).

A lack of data may provide ideas for compiling new data — as in projects like Femicide Kenya, Netra News’s Body Count and NRK’s De tomme kartene (The blank maps) — or shining a spotlight on its absence, as in the BBC and Guardian’s reports on the failure to record ethnicity of missing people and referrals to counter-extremism programmes.

Map with coloured points clustered in a selected area. Caption:
Og man kan jo bare tenke seg hva dere hadde funnet dersom dere hadde kartlagt et større område.
NRK’s De tomme kartene highlighted how official maps used for planning applications lacked key information by visiting an area and collecting data on flora and fauna in the area

Have I missed anything?

It’s likely there are other ethical considerations that haven’t been listed here, so please let me know if I’ve missed any out. Use the comments below or contact me on LinkedIn.

You can read more in the series of blog posts adapted from my book chapter on ethics in data journalism.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.